Does Failure Teach?
Your task
In a 2022 interview, Renata Okafor, a retired high school track coach from Bowie, Maryland, said: "People love to say failure is the best teacher. It isn't. Failure only teaches the people who are allowed to study it. Everyone else just gets hurt." Okafor's comment questions a familiar saying about failure and suggests that what someone learns from failing depends on their circumstances. Write an essay that argues your position on the extent to which failure is a valuable teacher. Draw on evidence from your reading, history, current events, or your own experience, and explain how each piece of evidence supports your reasoning.
Write
Your own words only
This essay must be written by you, here, in your own words. No AI tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Snapchat My AI or any other), no copying from websites or classmates, and no pasting. P-TECH follows PGCC's Code of Academic Integrity, and work that is not your own can earn an F. This page records how your essay is written — typing time, attempts to paste, leaving the page, and snapshots of your draft as it grows — and your teacher sees that record with your essay.
Score yourself
Be honest — the gap between your score and your teacher's is the most useful feedback you will get. Use the "what a strong response does" list below.
What a strong response does here
- Takes a defensible position on how far failure teaches, rather than simply agreeing that failure is good
- Engages Okafor's condition that people must be allowed to study their failure, such as time, support, or a second chance
- Uses specific evidence (an athlete, inventor, historical setback, or personal example) and explains what was actually learned
- Distinguishes between failures that build skill and failures that only cause harm
- Reasoning moves beyond summary to explain why the evidence proves the claim
- Acknowledges a complication, such as people who learned despite having no support
One defensible thesis: “Failure becomes a teacher only when it comes with room to reflect and a chance to try again, so schools, teams and workplaces that punish every mistake waste the very lessons they claim failure provides.”
ptechlargo.com is an independent tool built by the Largo P-TECH facilitator. It is not reviewed, approved, or endorsed by MSDE, PGCPS, PGCC, or the College Board. AP is a trademark of the College Board, used here only to describe the course. Your teacher's gradebook is the official record.