Skip to content
P-TECH IT

← All prompts

Rhetorical analysis · 40 minutes

Fill in the Boxes

Your task

In 2024, Mae Tolliver, a waterman who has fished the Chesapeake Bay off Smith Island, Maryland, for more than forty years, was invited to give the commencement address for the graduating class of an environmental science program at a Maryland community college. Tolliver has no college degree. In her speech, she describes the water-temperature calendar she has kept since 1983. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Tolliver makes to convince the graduates that patient, ordinary observation is the foundation of good science.

The passage

Fill in the Boxes — from a commencement address by Mae Tolliver to graduates of a community college environmental science program in Maryland, 2024

Good morning, graduates, families, and the faculty who taught these young people to measure things I only ever guessed at. I should tell you right away that I do not have a degree in anything. I have a boat named the Agnes Lee, a pair of hands that have pulled crab pots out of Tangier Sound for forty-one years, and a kitchen calendar where I have written down the water temperature every morning since 1983. When Dr. Okafor invited me to speak today, I asked her what a waterman could possibly teach people who know how to run a dissolved-oxygen sensor. She said, 'Tell them about the calendar.' So that is what I am going to do. My father never wrote anything down. He read the water the way you read a friend's face. He knew a hard winter was coming because the geese left early, and he knew the crabs would be thin because the grass beds near Ewell had gone brown. He was usually right. But when he was wrong, there was no way to know why, and no way to tell anyone else what he had seen. When he died, most of what he knew went into the ground with him. I started the calendar because I did not want that to happen to me. Every morning: the date, the water temperature off the dock, the wind, the number of bushels. Nothing fancy. A pencil and a feed-store calendar with a picture of a tractor on it. Some years I forgot for a week, and I left those boxes empty rather than guess, because a guess dressed up as a fact is worse than nothing. Here is what forty-one years of boxes taught me. The water off my dock is, on average, almost two degrees warmer in August than it was when I started. Two degrees does not sound like much. You would not notice it if you stuck your foot in. But the crabs notice. The grass notices. The oysters notice. My grandson, who is sitting in the third row trying not to look embarrassed, put my calendar into a spreadsheet last spring, and when he showed me the line climbing across the screen, I had to go outside and sit on the steps for a while. I am not telling you this to frighten you. I am telling you because every one of you is about to be handed a tool more powerful than my pencil, and I want you to remember what makes the pencil work. It is not the pencil. It is showing up every morning, especially the mornings when nothing interesting happens. Nobody gives you a prize for writing down an ordinary Tuesday. But the ordinary Tuesdays are where the truth is hiding. The storm gets the headline. The Tuesdays tell you whether the storm was unusual. You will be tempted, in your careers, to chase the exciting measurement: the fish kill, the record heat, the thing that gets your name in the paper. Chase those too. But do not skip the boring boxes. Somebody fifty years from now is going to need your Tuesdays. And do one more thing for me. Talk to people like my father. There are still men and women on these islands who know things no sensor has recorded yet: where the bottom shifted after the big hurricane in 2003, which coves used to freeze solid, what the water smelled like before the grass died. Most of them will never fill out a survey. But if you sit on the dock with them, and you are patient, and you do not act like you already know, they will tell you. Write it down. Put a date on it. Leave the box empty if you are not sure. The Bay does not care about our degrees. It does not care that I never finished school or that you just did. It only rewards the people who keep watching. I have been watching for forty-one years, and today I am handing the calendar to you. Fill in the boxes. Every morning. Thank you.

Write

Your own words only

This essay must be written by you, here, in your own words. No AI tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Snapchat My AI or any other), no copying from websites or classmates, and no pasting. P-TECH follows PGCC's Code of Academic Integrity, and work that is not your own can earn an F. This page records how your essay is written — typing time, attempts to paste, leaving the page, and snapshots of your draft as it grows — and your teacher sees that record with your essay.

40:00 left
0 words

Score yourself

Be honest — the gap between your score and your teacher's is the most useful feedback you will get. Use the "what a strong response does" list below.

What a strong response does here

One defensible thesis: “Speaking as an outsider to the graduates' world of sensors and spreadsheets, Tolliver converts her missing degree into a source of authority, uses the humble image of the calendar box and the 'ordinary Tuesday' to redefine scientific heroism as daily patience, and closes by literally handing her practice to the graduates, so that the commencement becomes a transfer of responsibility rather than a celebration of achievement.”

Thesis (0–1)
Evidence and commentary (0–4)
Sophistication (0–1)

ptechlargo.com is an independent tool built by the Largo P-TECH facilitator. It is not reviewed, approved, or endorsed by MSDE, PGCPS, PGCC, or the College Board. AP is a trademark of the College Board, used here only to describe the course. Your teacher's gradebook is the official record.