The following passage is a private letter written in 2023 by Curtis Wade, a long-haul truck driver from Hagerstown, Maryland, to his fifteen-year-old daughter, Nia. Before he left for a week-long trip, the two argued after Nia announced that she had quit her high school robotics team. Wade wrote the letter while on the road and left it for her to read before he returned. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Wade makes to repair his relationship with his daughter and encourage her to reconsider her decision without ordering her to change it.
The passage
The Unmailed Envelope — from a letter written by truck driver Curtis Wade to his fifteen-year-old daughter, 2023
Dear Nia,
I'm writing this from a truck stop outside Columbus, Ohio, because the last time we tried to talk about the robotics team, I said the wrong thing and you went upstairs, and then I had to leave at four in the morning before either of us could fix it. So I'm going to try again on paper, where I can cross things out.
First, the wrong thing. I said, 'You never finish anything.' That isn't true, and I knew it wasn't true while it was coming out of my mouth. You finished the 400 meters at the county meet with a cramp in your calf that made me want to run out onto the track. You finished reading every one of your grandmother's letters from Jamaica, even the ones in handwriting none of the rest of us can read. You finished the birdhouse in fourth grade, the one that still has a family of wrens in it. I was tired and I was scared, and I picked the sentence that would hurt the most. I'm sorry.
Now let me tell you what I was scared of, because I don't think I said that part at all.
When I was sixteen, I was good at drawing. Not refrigerator good. Really good. Mr. Haskins, my art teacher, wanted me to apply to a summer program at an art institute in Baltimore. I filled out half the application. Then I showed some of my drawings to a couple of guys on the football team, and one of them laughed, and I put the application in a drawer. I told myself it was because we couldn't afford the bus fare. That was partly true. Mostly I was embarrassed.
I've been driving a truck for twenty-two years. It's honest work and I'm proud of it, and it put the roof over your head. But some nights, parked somewhere like this, I sketch on the back of my logbook, and I wonder who I'd have turned into if I'd mailed that envelope.
You told me you quit because the team doesn't need you, because Marcus and Priya know more code than you do and you mostly just hold parts. Nia, I've watched you take apart the lawn mower engine and put it back together with one screw left over, and the thing ran better than before. You notice how things fit. That is not 'just holding parts.' Every crew I've ever worked with has the person who knows the rules and the person who knows the machine. Usually they are not the same person, and the job goes wrong when the second one goes home.
I'm not going to tell you to rejoin. You're fifteen, and this is your call, and if you really don't love it, then quitting is the right choice, and I'll back you all the way. But I want you to ask yourself one question, and answer it honestly, the way you'd answer it if nobody else was ever going to know: Did you quit because you don't like it, or because you were afraid of not being the best one in the room?
If it's the first, fine. Find the thing you do love and I'll drive you to it. If it's the second, then I'd like you to know that I've carried an unmailed envelope around for twenty-two years, and it's heavier than it looks.
The regional competition is in March. I already asked dispatch for that weekend off, just in case. If you're on the team, I'll be in the stands making too much noise. If you're not, we'll go get pancakes at the diner on Dual Highway and you can tell me what you'd rather be doing. Either way, I'm keeping the weekend.
I'll be home Thursday night. Leave the porch light on.
Love,
Dad
P.S. I drew the truck stop for you on the back of this. The coffee machine is not that crooked in real life. Or maybe it is.
Write
Your own words only
This essay must be written by you, here, in your own words. No AI tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Snapchat My AI or any other), no copying from websites or classmates, and no pasting. P-TECH follows PGCC's Code of Academic Integrity, and work that is not your own can earn an F. This page records how your essay is written — typing time, attempts to paste, leaving the page, and snapshots of your draft as it grows — and your teacher sees that record with your essay.
40:00left
0 words
Score yourself
Be honest — the gap between your score and your teacher's is the most useful feedback you will get. Use the "what a strong response does" list below.
What a strong response does here
Recognizes the private, one-reader rhetorical situation and explains why Wade opens with a specific, unqualified apology before making any argument
Analyzes the list of things Nia has finished as evidence that both refutes his own words and rebuilds her confidence
Explains how the story of the unmailed application shifts the letter from judgment to shared vulnerability, and how the envelope becomes a symbol
Examines the reframing of 'just holding parts' through the crew analogy of 'the person who knows the machine'
Discusses how the either/or question and the 'Either way, I'm keeping the weekend' promise preserve Nia's choice while still nudging her
Notes the effect of the informal voice, short sentences, and the humorous postscript on the father-daughter relationship
One defensible thesis: “Writing to a daughter he has just hurt, Wade earns the right to advise her by first dismantling his own accusation with concrete evidence, then exposing his own regret through the story of an unmailed application, so that his closing question feels less like a parent's command than an honest warning from someone who has carried the cost of quitting out of fear.”
ptechlargo.com is an independent tool built by the Largo P-TECH facilitator. It is not reviewed, approved, or endorsed by MSDE, PGCPS, PGCC, or the College Board. AP is a trademark of the College Board, used here only to describe the course. Your teacher's gradebook is the official record.