The following passage is from a 2024 opinion column by Renée Castillo, a certified athletic trainer who works at a public high school in Prince George's County, Maryland. The column was published in a regional newspaper at the start of the fall sports season and was aimed at parents of young athletes and the coaches of year-round club teams. Read the passage carefully. Write an essay that analyzes the rhetorical choices Castillo makes to persuade parents that allowing young athletes to rest and play more than one sport is better than year-round specialization in a single sport.
The passage
Let Them Rest — from an opinion column by athletic trainer Renée Castillo in a Maryland regional newspaper, 2024
Every August, a parent stops me outside the training room with the same question, phrased a dozen different ways. Is my kid falling behind? The question usually comes after a summer of travel tournaments, private lessons, and a showcase in another state. The kid is twelve or thirteen. The parent is not a bad parent. The parent is afraid.
I have been a certified athletic trainer for nineteen years, the last eleven at a public high school in Prince George's County. I want to answer that question honestly, because the honest answer is not the one the travel-ball industry is selling.
Your child is not falling behind. Your child may be wearing out.
Last school year, I evaluated forty-seven overuse injuries in athletes under eighteen: stress fractures in shins and lower backs, inflamed growth plates in elbows and knees, shoulders that clicked when a fifteen-year-old reached for a seatbelt. When I sorted my notes in June, thirty-eight of those forty-seven athletes played a single sport for at least nine months a year. Thirty-eight. These were not careless kids. They were the most dedicated athletes in the building. That was the problem.
A growing body is not a small adult body. The places where bones lengthen are softer than the bone around them, and when the same motion hammers the same spot for months without rest, something gives. A pitcher who throws year-round is asking the same patch of cartilage to absorb the same force thousands of times. A soccer player who never stops running is asking the same shinbone to rebuild faster than it can. Rest is not laziness. For a young athlete, rest is construction time.
I hear the counterargument, and I respect it. 'Everybody else is doing it. If my daughter takes the winter off, the coach will give her spot to someone who didn't.' I understand the fear, because I have watched it play out. But consider who benefits from that fear. A club that runs twelve months a year collects twelve months of fees. A showcase that convinces families their child must be seen at fourteen sells a lot of plane tickets. None of that is evidence that early specialization makes better athletes. It is evidence that it makes better business.
What does the evidence look like in my building? Look at our rosters. Of the athletes from our school who went on to play in college over the past five years, most played at least two sports through tenth grade. Our best defensive back wrestled every winter. Our state-qualifying distance runner played basketball until junior year, badly, by her own cheerful admission. The footwork she learned getting beaten off the dribble made her a smarter runner in a crowded pack. Different sports load the body differently and teach the brain different problems. The kids who crossed over were not behind. They were broader.
I am not asking you to pull your child out of anything. I am asking for three things. First, two or three months a year away from the main sport, spread across the calendar. Second, one full day of rest every week, a real one, with no 'light' practice. Third, a hard question at every sign-up table: What is this season for? If the honest answer is 'so they don't fall behind,' ask behind whom, and on what timeline.
Sometime in the next few weeks, a twelve-year-old will tell a parent that a knee hurts, and the parent will be tempted to say, 'Push through it, the tournament's Saturday.' I am asking that parent to pause. I would rather see your child on my table for ten minutes in seventh grade than for six months in eleventh.
The goal was never to win the summer before high school. The goal is a seventeen-year-old who still loves the game and still has two good knees to play it on. Let them rest. Let them try something else. Let them be kids whose bodies are still being built.
Write
Your own words only
This essay must be written by you, here, in your own words. No AI tools (ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot, Snapchat My AI or any other), no copying from websites or classmates, and no pasting. P-TECH follows PGCC's Code of Academic Integrity, and work that is not your own can earn an F. This page records how your essay is written — typing time, attempts to paste, leaving the page, and snapshots of your draft as it grows — and your teacher sees that record with your essay.
40:00left
0 words
Score yourself
Be honest — the gap between your score and your teacher's is the most useful feedback you will get. Use the "what a strong response does" list below.
What a strong response does here
Explains how Castillo opens by naming the parents' fear sympathetically ('The parent is not a bad parent') to lower their defenses
Analyzes the turn in the one-line paragraph 'Your child is not falling behind. Your child may be wearing out.' and how it reframes the issue
Discusses her use of her own injury count (38 of 47) and the construction metaphor ('rest is construction time') to combine data with explanation
Examines how she concedes the counterargument and then redirects suspicion toward the clubs' financial motives
Shows how the modest, specific requests and the contrast of 'ten minutes in seventh grade' versus 'six months in eleventh' make the change feel reasonable
Connects the repeated 'Let them' closing to her purpose of shifting parents' definition of success
One defensible thesis: “Castillo persuades anxious parents by first honoring their fear rather than scolding it, then replacing the vague threat of 'falling behind' with the concrete, firsthand evidence of injured children in her own training room, and finally redefining success as a healthy seventeen-year-old, so that resting a child sounds not like surrender but like the smartest form of ambition.”
ptechlargo.com is an independent tool built by the Largo P-TECH facilitator. It is not reviewed, approved, or endorsed by MSDE, PGCPS, PGCC, or the College Board. AP is a trademark of the College Board, used here only to describe the course. Your teacher's gradebook is the official record.